film

reviews










 

Brokeback Mountain (2005)

Director:
Ang Lee
COUNTRY
USA
GENRE
Drana/Romance
NORWEGIAN TITLE
Brokeback Mountain
RUNNING TIME
134 minutes
Producer:
Diana Ossana
James Schamus
Screenwriter (based on a short story by Annie Prolux):
Larry McMurty
Diana Ossana


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
Ennis Del Mar Heath Ledger
Jack Twist Jake Gyllenhaal
Joe Aguirre Randy Quaid
Lureen Newsome Anne Hathaway
Alma Michelle Williams

 

Review

Ang Lee directs this classically told love epic with conviction and great attention for his protagonists. It is a simple story, with simple characters whose sexuality might con people into thinking we're dealing with something original. Brokeback Mountain is a beautiful film, but it encounters problems when trying to span twenty years of the two separate lives of Jack Twist and Ennis Del Mar into short, episodic scenes that struggle to enlighten the development in its characters. Towards the end, we feel we're watching a 'highlights compilation' of a long-time doomed relationship.

By then though, the film has laid a solid foundation, mainly through a fine first half where Lee intertwines a beautiful back-to-basic portrayal of American frontier life with a forceful, passionate and primal romance that catches our protagonists unawares and sets off a highly interesting and riveting process in our men (particularly Ennis) that challenges and agonizes the rest of their lives. At its best, Brokeback Mountain is effective and probing, but there's also no denying that the simplicity of the story and the at times somwhat forced interaction and dialogue between our two not too talkative lovers puts a to some extent limiting vail to the experience. Ang Lee ultimately wraps it up quite usefully, but the often engaging and beautiful film still feels lacking during an overlong latter part.

Copyright 5.2.2006 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang

[BACK TO INDEX]

[HAVE YOUR SAY]