It Could Happen to You (1994)
This is a sweet little rom-com which is so unfashionable and ordinary-looking that you might just go along with its audacious premise. Nicolas Cage plays a virtuous New York cop who in lieu of money for tipping waitress Bridget Fonda decides to split any winnings from his lottery ticket with her. The only problem is that Cage's greedy, selfish wife (Rosie Perez) stands in their way. Director Andrew Bergman had dabbled in a similar territory together with Cage before, with the moderately successful Honeymoon in Vegas, and even if his direction lacks any kind of profoundness, there's a hint of authenticity to the story about Cage and Fonda's characters here and how the good old-fashioned Hollywood movie fate brings them together.