the fresh films reviews

S I N C E   1 9 9 7












 

 

Sophie's Choice (1982)

Directed by:
Alan J. Pakula
COUNTRY
USA
GENRE
Drama
NORWEGIAN TITLE
Sophies valg
RUNNING TIME
157 minutes
Produced by:
Alan J. Pakula
Keith Barish
Written by (based on the novel by William Styron):
Alan J. Pakula


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
Sophie Zawistowska Meryl Streep
Nathan Landau Kevin Kline ½
Stingo Peter MacNicol

 

Review

Alan J. Pakula (almost single-handedly) adapted William Styron's multi-layered novel to the screen, and the result was this film that delves into some of the most tragic and complex aspects of WWII. The story follows a young, initially naïve American narrator who becomes entangled with a tightly bound, seemingly self-destructive European couple. While the individual character histories hold interest, Pakula struggles to weave all his thematic strands into a cohesive whole, leaving many of the film’s conclusions and narrative developments feeling forced and unnatural. Kevin Kline's character serves as the main source of suspense, but Kline's performance is overdone, and the character's mysterious past remains frustratingly opaque. Maintaining suspense in a drama like this demands more dynamic pacing than Pakula delivers here. Nevertheless, there are moments of genuine emotional impact – particularly as we're introduced to Meryl Streep’s character and the haunting scene that gives the film its title. But despite the brilliance of Streep’s performance, including an impressively authentic accent, she is rarely supported by Pakula’s somewhat pretentious direction. And the parallel love story involving Peter MacNicol lacks chemistry and fails to ignite, leaving the film struggling under the weight of its own ambitions.

Copyright © 07.09.2004 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang [HAVE YOUR SAY]