the fresh films reviews

S I N C E   1 9 9 7











 

Secretary (2002)

Directed by:
Steven Shamberg

COUNTRY
USA

GENRE
Erotic drama/Romance

NORWEGIAN TITLE
Secretary

RUNNING TIME
107 minutes

Produced by:
Steven Shamberg
Andrew Fierberg
Amy Hobby

Written by (based on the short story by Mary Gaitskill):
Erin Cressida Wilson


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
E. Edward Grey James Spader
Lee Holloway Maggie Gyllenhaal ½
Peter Jeremy Davies ½
Dr. Twardon Patrick Bauchau -
Burt Holloway Stephen McHattie -
Jonathan Oz Perkins -
Tricia O'Connor Jessica Tuck -
Joan Holloway Lesley Ann Warren -

 

Review

After having once forced myself through David Cronenberg's very peculiar Crash, I never thought I’d find myself enjoying a performance by James Spader as a character with unusual sexual preferences. However, in Steven Shainberg’s inventive Secretary, both Spader’s introspective and repressed E. Edward Grey and Maggie Gyllenhaal’s wonderfully quirky Lee Holloway are thematic and stylistic sensations. Secretary unfolds with such shameless confidence and spontaneous playfulness that it comes across as a seductive splash of colour. In addition to the oddities and unusual charm of the two leads, Shainberg also demonstrates an undeniable talent for delicate compositions and alluring colour palettes. Unfortunately, he doesn’t quite stick the landing, as by the end, the film becomes too preoccupied with providing answers and tying up narrative arcs. What a unique story like this doesn’t need is an undue desire to "normalise" it all in the sugary spirit of family traditions. By preserving more of the mystery surrounding Spader’s character and (naturally) omitting the tiresomely typical media circus introduced in the final act, Shainberg’s abstract world would have retained more of its immediate appeal. Still, by that point, we’ve already been seduced, engaged, and perhaps even slightly sexually aroused.

Copyright © 12.03.2004 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang
(English version: © 11.01.2025 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang)
[HAVE YOUR SAY]