|
|
Birth
(2004)
|
Director:
Jonathan
Glazer |
COUNTRY
USA |
GENRE
Drama/Mystery/Thriller |
NORWEGIAN
TITLE
Birth |
RUNNING
TIME
110
minutes |
|
Producer:
Lizie Gower
Nick Morris
Jean-Louis Piel |
Screenwriter:
Jean-Claude
Carriére
Milo Addica
Jonathan Glazer |
Review
Perhaps
in some other medium, or with another approach or another director, Birth
could have been an interesting concept. The problem is that this film is
not able whatsoever to make the issue it raises relevant. Your dead
husband returns after ten years, but this time in the body of a ten year
old kid. Can you empathizes with that? Well, neither can Nicole Kidman,
and far less young Cameron Bright. He's totally defenceless against the
horrible dialogue he's given. And of course, one cannot expect him to be
able to come off as a grown, sexual man with any kind of credibility. It
doesn't help much that the movie is thoroughly detached, directed
apparently without insight or commitment by Jonathan Glazer. Every
character acts and speaks as if they had never been people, and just had
been granted a trial, making this film awkward at its best.
|
|